Backers of alternative Asda plan pleased by response

By Emily Pearce

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

 

Backers of alternative Asda plan pleased by response

South Coast Leisure’s Tony Wake talks to Doreen, left, and Rachel Stone about the Newport FC plans. Picture by Jennifer Burton.

ALTERNATIVE plans for a new Asda store have proved a hit with the public but have yet to convince planners or supermarket bosses.

South Coast Leisure (SCL), the company that owns Newport Football Club’s ground, next to Asda’s preferred site off St George’s Way, has said it was delighted with the response to its plans at a recent public exhibition in Newport.

But Asda has made it clear it intends to stick to its preferred scheme after submitting a long-awaited planning application late last year.

It has accused SCL of trying to foil its plans by stepping in at the last minute with a rival proposal.

Furthermore, SCL has no formal agreement with the Isle of Wight Council to relocate Newport Football Club to council-owned land east of the current ground — a key element of SCL’s proposal which, it says, would safeguard the long-term future of the club. In fact, the council has a contractual agreement with Asda over the land.

Despite these hurdles, SCL’s major shareholder Tony Wake, formerly of Wake’s Carpet Superstore, said he was 100 per cent sure the council’s planning committee would favour the company’s yet-to-be-submitted application over Asda’s.

Speaking after the exhibition, he said: "We were very pleased with the response. No-one said they preferred the original Asda proposal. Once people realised how different our scheme was, that it brought the store closer to the town centre, had more parking and would benefit the football club, they were all for it."

Of the 88 people who returned feedback forms at the event, 86 supported SCL’s plans and two made no comment.

"We have never tried to hide the fact that selling the football ground to Asda will make us money. Business is about making money. But everyone can win with our plans, and I’m sure Asda and the council will see ours is the better course," said Mr Wake.

Reporter: emilyp@iwcpmail.co.uk

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?
Displaying the last 10 of 17 comments - Show All Comments

Log-in to Report

by kevin froment

5th February 2013, at 18:24:34

as its their land i think it only right that they keep it, after all it was the prefered site for the ground once, what has changed other than the owners want to cash in, if as i said before, asda wanted that piece of land ive no doubt they would have submitted an offer, but they didnt so they obviously dont. i doubt the paultry amount of returned surveys will convince anyone that the new proposal is anything but a small bump in a very big plan. there are many times more wanting asda than dont so let them come and have an end to the bickering

Log-in to Report

by Jake Wallace

5th February 2013, at 17:51:46

Let them cash in on their land .. i guess it's the reason it's called their land

But the truth is there is a nice bit of land around that area which they could just concrete over ... or they could turn into a nice natural area with walking route into town, quiet riversides to take in. outside cafe areas would do well away from the main road ... something to take away the doom & gloom of the isle of concrete as a few on here belive it to soon be

Log-in to Report

by Stephen Elliott

5th February 2013, at 17:38:01

These people that say yes are those that have visited/pulled into the church. Joke survey carried out by those that step forward. People don't care other than that we get an Asda. SCL just want to cash in on their land

Log-in to Report

by Jake Wallace

5th February 2013, at 17:31:01

I think he's got good mind to think ahead of a time where newport football club might outgrow it's venue & then what .. no one excect Asda are going to want the land .. but at a greatly lower price .. devaluing our island even more.

I say make them take up the land .. improve the area around it .. look what sainsbury did to that bit of waste land at the botttom of hunneyhill. If that development hadn't gone ahead .. what would become of that giant housing estate they have now put up, would that of even gone ahead.

So come the day that newport footbal club wants to move & has no money to do so .. what do we do except complain that we should of made asda pay for the premium bit of land on one of the least congregated bits of road leading into newport.

Do we just thrown in the towel & say o well, we never needed state of the art grounds .. seaclose will do just as well .. cept for festival days & months afterwards where nothing is usuable up there

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

5th February 2013, at 14:19:35

Its not a matter of stepping in at the last minuet to foil anything its a proposal of what the people want after all they do live here of all the cheek and gaul

Log-in to Report

by Jim Buchanan

5th February 2013, at 14:13:42

'In fact, the council has a contractual agreement with Asda over the land.'
So if a contractual agreement is already in place between the Council and Asda, what are the odds of Asda's plans being approved, especially as Asda only recently submitted a planning application? Mmmm, let me think on that one...

Log-in to Report

by Warren Copland

5th February 2013, at 13:37:36

Just get it built!

Log-in to Report

by ROBERT SMITH

5th February 2013, at 12:50:08

Alan Hunter what's MANUFACTURING? the tories killed that OFF.
ASDA must come to the island have you looked at the prices of basic items in TESCO, MORISSONS and I cannot remember the last time I spent any money in the CO-OP. SORRY to the small keeper every where buy Iv got to eat.

Log-in to Report

by Phil New

5th February 2013, at 11:36:51

88 people returned their feedback forms.Thousands didnt bother coz they know SCL are being greedy. Let ASDA get on with it and matey can go back to his carpets.

Log-in to Report

by Mrs James

5th February 2013, at 11:03:08

Ive said it before, I say it again, I want ASDA here and am happy with their plan. As a Disabled Person, Ive given them a lot of Access ideas and offered to give my time freely to assist them in creating Access For All... I have found them ready to listen and take onboard local peoples suggestions and requests...
I do find the comment from Mr Wake a bit worying to say the least as in "said he was 100 per cent sure the council’s planning committee would favour the company’s yet-to-be-submitted application over Asda’s." How can he be 100% sure ...???

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Delicious Icon

More News

1 - 2 - 3 - 4