Call for talks to avoid festival chaos repeat

By a County Press reporter

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

 

IN THE wake of last Thursday and Friday's transport problems surrounding the Isle of Wight Festival, the Isle of Wight Council has called for urgent talks to make sure they do not happen again.

Cllr George Brown, Cabinet member for economy and licensing, said the congestion should not have happened and urged people not to use the issues as an excuse to undermine what was a successful event.

His full statement said: "The congestion problems that occurred on Thursday and Friday were unacceptable. 

"They should not have happened and should not be allowed to happen again. Whilst some level of disruption will always occur, this has previously been manageable at a level that Island residents can work around.

"Unexpected and heightened levels of disruption this year caused understandable frustration and anger. I have much sympathy for those whose personal circumstances were affected to an intolerable extent.

"We now need, as a matter of priority, to sit down with the organisers and our partners to confirm exactly what went wrong, and why. We need to agree what must be done to ensure that such problems do not arise again.

"The Isle of Wight Council follows this process each year with organisers and partners but the wash-up this time will clearly have new urgency and focus.

"A calm, measured approach is required on all fronts. Decisions about changes in practice have to be based on facts and evidence, not soundbites and kneejerk reactions. The Island must not lose sight of the great benefits – both economical and cultural – that the festival brings.

"Let’s not forget also that many thousands of the people who attended last weekend’s event are Island people, who can now enjoy artists of a calibre that not so long ago they could never have dreamed of seeing here.

"I write as the Cabinet Member for the Economy and Licensing, when I say that this year’s problems should not be used to undermine or compromise an event that is so important to the Island, its economy, its profile and to a great many of its residents.

"The festival puts many millions into the Island’s economy each year. Less tangible, though equally welcome, is the substantial cultural benefit the event brings, and the profile it gives to the Island as a destination for a new generation of visitors.



"Regrettable though the unacceptable level of congestion was, it need not happen again as our arrangements for the departure of those attending the festival clearly demonstrated. 

"It is evident that ground conditions at the festival car parks, which are under the control of the organisers, caused a massive build up of traffic at the site, with a knock-on effect on roads for miles around.

"Given the heavy rainfall before people arrived, contingency plans for the parking area and alternatives simply did not stand up to the pressure. A far more weatherproof arrangement will be required for future events.

"Council officers deserve much credit for their emergency actions and for the plans they developed with partners for getting traffic away after the event. 

"A small team of officers worked almost without sleep during the crucial period and they have rightly been praised by those, including members of the public, who saw them in action. 

"The smoothness of the exit arrangements was a testimony to the collective work by all concerned.

"I will not be joining those who are calling for sanctions against the festival organisers or who attribute the problems to numbers attending.

"We have now had 11 festivals –some of which have been larger than this one – without experiencing this year’s degree of difficulties. 

"Failure in contingency plans around the event car parks is an issue that can be resolved effectively without a heavy hand or unhelpful recrimination. 

"The council will have a positive role to play in this process and I believe the input of our local knowledge will be key to achieving more resilience in future."

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?

Log-in to Report

by Don Prescott

28th June 2012, at 14:57:19

I can't believe that I am reading this : "We now need, as a matter of priority, to sit down with the organisers and our partners to confirm exactly what went wrong, and why." from the man who is in charge of planning (so people say), the economy AND licensing!!
This is not the ruddy 9 times table!
The weather was atrocious. Rain kept falling. HGVs entered the site and churned up the grass/topsoil for days prior to the start of Festival.
Punters could not drive onto the site because they did NOT come in tractors. They were mostly in 2 wheel drive vehicles.
Perhaps they should have all come on pushbikes like some fools want!
WHAT part of that do people need to SIT down and discuss?
Has the IOW metamorphosed into the E.U.?
Is Herman Van Rumplestiltskin now running the IOW?

Log-in to Report

by kevin staples

28th June 2012, at 13:28:25

The festival is great for Red Funnel and Southern Vectis, both mainland companies and the festival organisers and all the mainland bands and support personnel from the mainland.As for island businesses the bus company has resorted to scare tactics and selling tickets before people arrive on the island so as to cut local taxi firms and shops out of the equation by bussing them straight to site.Sure Sainsburys etc made some money as did the IWCC and i would imagine a fair few free tickets too. As a former Taxi driver i brought my concerns to the Licensing department two years running and as usual with their so called consultations nothing came out of it. In fact they tried to push the blame back on the taxi drivers for last years appalling drop off proceedures, even to the extent of telling us we could not drop off on the roadside even though the field was muddy and cars were slipping backwards towards festival goers causing a hazard and stranding many Taxis. The numbers may add up for t

Log-in to Report

by ROBERT DALTON

28th June 2012, at 00:00:11

JOHN Giddings has a cheek to say the IOW has benefited from the past 10 years of festivals on the island but so has he! The amount of money he has made on the back of the island is tremendous, and we allow it. I was unable to return to my home thursday night and had to sleep in shanklin and make special arrangments to borrow medicine to get by. What about compensating the island for all the trouble it caused for a great many of us? Better still donate a extra amount to our hospice as a matter of goodwill.

Log-in to Report

by Michael Jackson

27th June 2012, at 15:39:25

LOL

Log-in to Report

by Paul Strauss

27th June 2012, at 11:13:28

Apologies for the confusion Mr Jackson - my mistake. But on this point - I was actually Christened 'Johann' but decided to change my name by deed-poll to Paul as I was forever being confused with the 19th century Austrian composer. Have you considered changing to a more workaday name - perhaps Glenda or Colin?

Log-in to Report

by phil cooper

27th June 2012, at 11:06:33

I believe the Isle of Wight Steam Railway is the biggest tourist attraction on the Island, with many travelling from the mainland via public transport. So how did the Festival affect their weekend's business? It would be interesting to know whether numbers were reduced and by what percentage. If this was extrapolated to the whole Island, we would have some indicator to the economic cost of the Festival to Island businesses. It's time we had some accurate numbers to put against the oft-quoted millions the Festival earns.

Log-in to Report

by Dan Skelton

27th June 2012, at 10:08:37

I hear planning is a good idea, might wanna try it sometime.

Log-in to Report

by Michael Jackson

27th June 2012, at 09:56:42

Very funny,remind me to laugh.

Log-in to Report

by Paul Strauss

27th June 2012, at 09:49:03

Mr Jackson - your comments astound me! As one of the world's most successful recording artistes, albeit dead, I would have expected you to have thrown your full support behind the festival.

Log-in to Report

by Michael Jackson

27th June 2012, at 09:40:21

.When its said events like this benefit the "local economy" what they really mean is it fills a few busnessmen/womens pockets. How many extra permanent jobs will be created because of the festival?. Very few I would think.

Log-in to Report

by Julie Taylor

27th June 2012, at 08:44:10

I live and work in Ryde and during the festival weekend many many of our local business benefit a great deal from this weekend, I have friends who owns a small business in east cowes and this is also a very busy time for them. The boast to the local economy is fantastic. Lets not forget many of these festival goers are our future tourists!

Log-in to Report

by Deborah Alexander

27th June 2012, at 08:43:41

I would like to understand how the island benefits financially from the festival, many shopkeepers say trade is really slack as residents avoid Newport during festival weekend. I would like the festival to continue and I'm sure it will, however it would be good for island residents to be given a factual analysis of how it helps our economy. I hear and read so many things I don't know what to believe.

Log-in to Report

by Robert Cleverdon

27th June 2012, at 08:11:37

To conclude:
If the capacity is severely cut back, the quality of artist that the organiser could afford would fall, making the festival less attractive and possibly leading to a downward spiral. This would be damaging for the Island's economy and image.

Log-in to Report

by Robert Cleverdon

27th June 2012, at 08:09:18

The economic benefits to the Island need to be demonstrated through a rigorous piece of research. Many Islanders react sceptically to the various claims of '£10 million' or 'many millions' so a clear illustration of how much the Island gains, and in what ways, would do much to correct these reactions - though there will always be the naysayers in the community. Apart from the direct economic benefit and the fact that this event is enjoyed by thousands of Islanders, two other positive factors are: the image of the Island as a tourist destination is boosted by the music festivals breaking the mould of it being a destination only for families and the elderly, thus broadening the market segments attracted to the Island; and, second, the festivals plant the seeds for future tourists, many of the young festival goers returning to the Island in years to come remembering the good time they had when they came to the festival. Finally, if the capacity is severely cut back, the quality of a

Log-in to Report

by kevin froment

26th June 2012, at 22:28:25

i would like to see a breakdown of the "many millions" that are put into the islands economy. if it was proven to me and plenty of others who have voiced opinions on these pages that indeed many millions were made by local businesses, with local headquarters and staffed by local people then i would be the first to congratulate them all, sadly though i dont think this will happen

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Delicious Icon

More News

1 - 2 - 3 - 4

Most Read

  1. Ferry involved in yacht collision

    Friday, May 24, 2013

  2. Plan to end contractor deal for top officer

    Friday, May 24, 2013

  3. Dragon disappears from garden

    Friday, May 24, 2013

  4. UB40 gig called off

    Friday, May 24, 2013

  5. UB40 gig rescheduled

    Friday, May 24, 2013