Call for voting age to be lowered

By a County Press reporter

Thursday, January 24, 2013

 

AS MPs discuss a motion calling for the voting age to be lowered, the Isle of Wight's Member of Youth Parliament has urged people to support the idea.

A motion put forward by Bristol MP Stephen Williams, opened a debate on the issue in the House of Commons today (Thursday).

Isle of Wight Member of Youth Parliament Robert Selby said there were many arguments to support giving young people a greater input in policy making.

"There is great emphasis put on what 16 year olds can already do by law, such as give full consent to medical treatment, leave school and enter work or training, get married or enter a civil partnership, consent to sexual relationships, join the armed forces and much more.

"I would also like to draw to the fact that 16 year olds pay income tax and National Insurance and can obtain tax credits and welfare benefits in their own right, which leads to the famous phrase: 'No taxation without representation’, for it is this argument that led to the American Revolution."

He said teenagers had been affected by a number of decisions recently, including cuts to the Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA) and the rise in tuition fees.

He said: "Legislation and cuts like these that directly affect us, we should be able to vote.    

"Many critics of the enfranchisement say other members of a young person’s household would influence their vote.

"This is the exact same justification that the critics of female enfranchisement used, 100 years ago, for 'they were not mature enough’, this is an exact parallel; we are free thinking individuals with diverse opinions.      

"I plead for anyone to support this bill, for with even with all these arguments, the real issue is democracy, and it always has been. We have a right to vote."

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story. See our House Rules here.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?

Log-in to Report

by Mike Crowe

27th January 2013, at 17:17:45

and James, it is a criminal offence to photograph a child of under 18, (or is it 17? Forgot what they said at the Camera Club and it's not my subject) in the nude!! ....... ""Child of under ......"" .......Child!!??

So going on that, no don't lower the age of voting to "children" ;-)

Log-in to Report

by James McAdder

25th January 2013, at 17:28:27

It's kind of ironic that, at 16, you can legally get up to stuff you aren't allowed to watch others getting up to in 18 rated movies.

Log-in to Report

by G Day

25th January 2013, at 08:29:54

I personally can't see the point. Apart from making the 16-17 years olds feel more mature than they actually are, I can't see many of them taking it seriously. As for forcing people to vote and fining those who don't - it's bad enough we are obliged by law to do many things in this country, apparently this is still a democratic state (doesn't feel like it) so it is my choice to vote or not as I see fit; and having voted a few times I have never gone to the polling station with excitement and trepidation that great changes are on the horizon.

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

25th January 2013, at 00:19:31

i should like to comment on the VOTING coming up on the isle off wight shortly I feel and I hope the web master for the county press agrees the on voting day for local and island councils should be highlighted in the county press front page urging people to vote this proceedure shoud be most important to the islands future and i o w readers not stuck up in the corner of some remote village hall notice board that nobody reads I read so many unhappy people by the way things are being run at the moment

Log-in to Report

by Mike Crowe

24th January 2013, at 22:50:25

I would take the vote away from some adults I don't know about lowering it!

Log-in to Report

by Valerie Ching

24th January 2013, at 21:15:21

While I personally do not agree with lowering the voting age to 16 I believe it should remain at 18 - current age of majority - in my view the Island MYP has set out a very reasoned and persuasive case for to support his stance,, which prompts further thought on the matter. Given the low standard of debate all too often displayed lately in the House of Commons often just trading personal insults, I find the MYP's clarity, passion and evident sincerity in championing his cause on its merits as he sees them and without special pleading a refreshing change from the dreary self-interested expediency politics and weak bleatings instead of policies you can hear any day of the week all around, and not just from politicians.

Log-in to Report

by Kevin Barclay-Jay

24th January 2013, at 14:18:45

at 16 you can be married and fully contrtibute to society and should be the legal limit for voting..as to maturity,,,,maybe a retirement from voting would be a good idea :)........and make it a legal requirement to vote

Log-in to Report

by ROBERT SMITH

24th January 2013, at 13:58:30

DONT lower the voting age FINE anyone who doent vote that would be better.

Log-in to Report

by tony white

24th January 2013, at 13:10:56

I personally think 16 is too young to be able to vote, the present age limit at least allows them to achieve some degree of maturity when they can make decisions based on real life experience rather than the artificial classroom environment

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

24th January 2013, at 13:07:31

Can somone tell me were Mr Turner stands on this proposal

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.