Commission criticised over consultation website

By Ross Findon

Wednesday, March 7, 2012


Commission criticised over consultation website

THE RELEASE of public responses to Boundary Commission plans to split the Isle of Wight into two constituencies has been criticised by Island MP Andrew Turner.

The public responses to Boundary Commission proposals to carve up the Isle of Wight into two were published online on a specially created website yesterday (Tuesday), inviting people to comment on the representations.

Mr Turner told the County Press the way the information was presented was flawed, as it did not allow users to search for responses specific to the Isle of Wight.

He said: "This four week consultation period is supposed to be for people to comment on the representations which have been received.

"But it will take you four weeks to read the 5,000 plus responses that have been submitted for the south east.

"People on the Isle of Wight are unlikely to want to comment on what is happening in Buckinghamshire and Kent.

"I am writing to the commission to point this out and am copying it to the deputy prime minister Nick Clegg, who is responsible for the Boundary Commission."

He added said the website gave the views of political parties undue prominence, when it was the public views that were more important.

Under the Boundary Commission proposals, originally announced in September, last year, the Isle of Wight faces a north-south divide, creating an Isle of Wight North and an Isle of Wight South.

That split has been supported by Labour and the Conservatives, however in their response Lib-Dems said the split should be east to west.

Isle of Wight North would be geographically smaller but would include the urban areas of Cowes, Newport and Ryde.

It would also contain East Cowes, Gurnard, Northwood, Parkhurst, Whippingham and Osborne, Wootton Bridge, Binstead and Fishbourne and Seaview and Nettlestone.

The rest of the Island, including Carisbrooke, which would be split from Newport, would form a new rural seat called Isle of Wight South extending from The Needles in the west to Bembridge in the east.

The boundary follows the line which divided the former local authorities of Medina and South Wight Borough Council before a local government re-organisation scrapped the district councils.

The number of voters in each division would be around the same, with 56,253 in the north and 54,671 in the south.

The Conservatives support a North-South divide but the Liberal Democrats are calling for an East-West split.

Both the Tories and Labour do not agree with the proposal to divide the Havenstreet, Ashey and Haylands ward from Ryde. They want to see the ward united with Ryde in the Isle of Wight North seat.

They also propose the inclusion of Nettlestone and Seaview ward, which has ties with St Helens and Bembridge ward, in theĀ Isle of Wight South constituency.

Meanwhile, the Liberal Democrats support an East-West split, thereby ensuring no town, village or natural community is split between two seats.

Thousands of responses were submitted to the commission and are available to read online at the Boundary Commission webpage.

The final proposals are scheduled to be put to parliament in October, 2013.


Log-in or register to comment on this story. See our House Rules here.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?

Log-in to Report

by Mrs Carmelle James

7th March 2012, at 22:25:26

I think we should just have an Island Mayor and I would say they should be able to put themselves forward or be nominated by individuals, then then go about telling / showing us why we should vote them in, my first 2 nominations would be Pete Harris and a chap called Jay ... They should be able to stand for Mayor without having to pay any fee to do so...
I think dividing the Island is just rediculas ...
United we Stand Divided we Fall...

Log-in to Report

by Liam Thom

7th March 2012, at 17:39:20

Re: Kevin Barclay-Jay.
Actually our MP (and the IWCP and all three parties) campaigned for no Isle of Wight constituency to be shared with the mainland.

Log-in to Report

by Kevin Barclay-Jay

7th March 2012, at 14:24:34

of course Turner is going to criticise...he campaigned to save HIS IIsland for himself and deny us democracy...well yet again, he lost and democracy won...hopefully we will get a dynamic and representative MP...or at least one of them

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Delicious Icon

More News

1 - 2 - 3 - 4

Most Read

  1. Missing man's body found

    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

  2. Road closed after collision

    Wednesday, July 30, 2014

  3. Public meeting proposal over floating bridge

    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

  4. Birthday party on Britain's oldest pier

    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

  5. Young people taste success

    Tuesday, July 29, 2014

View our Elgin Traffic & Travel Map