Council tax plans under fire

By David Newble

Thursday, September 20, 2012

 

CONTROVERSIAL plans to cut council tax benefit for low income families and scrap the discount for second homes on the Isle of Wight have been branded as unfair by a leading councillor.

The council is considering proposals that would mean 7,900 residents, who have their council tax paid through benefits, having to pay up to 20 per cent of their bills from April next year.

The plans were discussed at a full council meeting last night (Wednesday).

The move follows the government’s decision to abolish the national council tax benefit scheme and replace it with locally run schemes. The Isle of Wight Council needs to find an extra £1.9m a year to cover its costs, due to a cut in government support.

However, Liberal Democrat, Cllr Reg Barry told members he could only support a system that was fair and which treated every council tax payer the same.

He said: "Where does the idea come from that everybody who has the misfortune to find themselves out of work and in need of the support that benefits bring are work shy and to stop a percentage of their benefits will make them go and take up all these jobs that are going begging? What jobs?"

Labour councillor, Geoff Lumley said that the scheme was a 'classic example’ of what Lady Thatcher’s government did in the 1980s, making local government impose cuts from central government.

He said: "This is something that will bite the government in the back."

However, the Isle of Wight Council leader, Cllr David Pugh, told members that the authority was obliged to draw up its own scheme.

He said: "The overall cost of the welfare state is unaffordable and this is how the government seeks to reduce it."

Members voted to go ahead with the consultation on the proposals, which will run from Monday, until November 10.

The final scheme must be agreed in January.

Reporter: davidn@iwcpmail.co.uk

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story. See our House Rules here.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?

Log-in to Report

by ROBERT SMITH

21st September 2012, at 00:17:05

Terry Dalley.. YOU are TOTALLY WRONGE if labour had followed Thatcher's way of dictating this country would have unemployment at the last election at less than 3 million but it would have been more like 5 to 6 million if not more. Then HOW would call me DAVE and his lap dog NICK woof CLEGG have been able to peddle their CON / LIB lies about the economy being broken. They still haven put all the people back to work that they got rid of when they conned their way into no 10.So dont come here that its we labour that put us in this position. CAN you see this county better under this CON / LIB government after nearly three years and dont say IT WILL takes time cause it will when you have NO ideas how to get us out of IT. LOOK around you and see how this county are going down the toilet in JUS

Log-in to Report

by ROBERT SMITH

20th September 2012, at 23:56:12

GO on get rid of the 2nd home rate. THEN watch the home marked CRASH when all US second homes owners PUT our homes on the marked. Because it US second home owners that ONLY live in them for less than a quarter of the year in my case THAT means Im PAYING MORE council tax than YOU for less of a service to begin with, IN that case the remained of YOU should be paying MORE council tax because YOU are using MORE.....SO THINK ON.

Log-in to Report

by Terry Dalley

20th September 2012, at 21:31:01

This just shows the mentality of this Labour councillor to blame Maggie Thatcher .it is the labour party that has got us into this situation and not Maggie when she was in charged if you worked you got on .the Labour Party reversed this ethic until we have a generation that has not had to work .Heshould shut up or resign if this is the best he can do.

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

20th September 2012, at 17:10:48

I agree the dicount for 2 nd homes should be cut no country in the world allows dicounts in tax on 2 nd homes including America of course you are an aristotic controled country and many many rich and royalty favered aristocrats ocupy grace and favered homes NO TAX also members of parliment have very very large 2 nd homes your local M P for instance of course everyone knows this d ont they

Log-in to Report

by Robert Drover

20th September 2012, at 16:56:32

Scrapping the second home discount is not sufficient to counter the fdamage caused to everyone sruggling to buy a home or paying off a mortgage on an inflated price.
the rate charged should five times the rate for the property---at least.!

Log-in to Report

by Kevin Barclay-Jay

20th September 2012, at 11:38:52

This is just nonsense...this awfulcouncil trys to blame government cuts, but has already over cut on this years budget..they recently reported that they had 'found; a couple of hundred grand...how very fortunate for them...and they are going to use it to put on an asparagus festival....whilst families starve because they implement tory ideology

Log-in to Report

by Lee Majors

20th September 2012, at 11:09:06

Get rid of Mr Turner, use his 50k expenses to help pay these poor families bills

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.