Criticism after PFI debate 'blocked'

By Martin Neville

Thursday, January 17, 2013

 

Criticism after PFI debate 'blocked'

Cllr Jonathan Bacon.

ISLE of Wight Tories were branded anti-democratic for blocking debate on the multi-million pound highways PFI last night (Thursday).

Independent councillor Chris Welsford brought a motion before the full council, claiming the decision to award the contract to Vinci Concessions breached the Isle of Wight Council constitution because it was made without full knowledge of the facts.

He said important information about the need for an asphalt plant to deliver the PFI contract was not disclosed when the decision was made in May.

However, the debate came to a grinding halt after Cllr Barry Abraham moved to use a procedural rule to skip to the next agenda item without further discussion.

The Tory councillor’s motion was passed by 19 votes to nine, prompting a brief walk out by independents and anger from the public gallery.

Cllr Jonathan Bacon, who wanted to speak at the meeting but was prevented by the sudden guillotine, said afterwards: "This is ridiculous. The Conservative administration cannot face having any form of sensible debate about its approach to running this council.

"To block debate and discussion not only suggests they are undemocratic but also they have something to hide."

Before the debate ended, council leader Cllr David Pugh said the PFI was not dependent on the contractor setting up an asphalt plant and the planning application for Medina Wharf and the highways PFI were entirely separate processes.

"The plant wasn’t part of their bid or a requirement of the contract," he said.

Reporter: martinn@iwcpmail.co.uk

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?
Displaying the last 10 of 15 comments - Show All Comments

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

20th January 2013, at 22:04:43

VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTEVOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE VOTE GET YOUR FREINDS TO VOTE GET YOUR FREINDS TO VOTE GET YOUR NIEGHBOUR TO VOTE GET SIGN S ON YOUR CARE NOW PUT SIGN S OUT IF YOU D ONT VOTE THEN SHAME ON YOU FOR NOT CARING FOR YOUR KIDS

Log-in to Report

by geoffrey clynch

19th January 2013, at 13:06:02

Exactly Mr.Bennett, providing we can be sure that the elections are not rigged, one way of doing this is to build thousands of new houses and fill them with immigrants who will out vote the indigenous people

Log-in to Report

by Alan Bennett

19th January 2013, at 01:40:59

Remember, if you do not vote them out at the next elections, then do not come on here to complain. We can carp on for years and form committee's etc etc, but the ballot box has the power to achieve what we want and need. Lets set new standards and elect a Council that is 100% accountable and if they sell us short, than they go!

Log-in to Report

by Alan Bennett

19th January 2013, at 01:36:09

Paul, whist I appreciate your response is in keeping with the acceptance that we we will NEVER get a truthful response from IW Council, I am sorry to say it does not help our case.

Log-in to Report

by Paul Strauss

18th January 2013, at 15:18:47

If I was Councillor Bacon, I would use my Tardis to go back in time to prevent Councillor Abraham's parents from ever meeting. Then I would grab a guileless and sweetly pretty assistant, and make off back to the future. Then at the meeting last night, in the absence of the erased-from-history Councillor Abraham and his meddling, I could have enjoyed a satisfactory conclusion to an important debate, before dashing off with my assistant and K-9 to battle some Daleks somewhere.

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

18th January 2013, at 14:19:36

Keep a very close eye on the AGEANT of the company theres always leakages if there has been already

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

18th January 2013, at 14:15:44

Looks like a london SPIV to me

Log-in to Report

by geoffrey clynch

18th January 2013, at 13:38:04

this takes us back to the American Revolution.."NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION"

Log-in to Report

by geoffrey clynch

18th January 2013, at 13:25:47

1997 Britain became a DICTATORSHIP, and pugh and his ilk are the quisling lackies of the Lib/Lab/CON/EU dictatorship, and some will be making a financial gain out of this, DEMOCRACY, none of these COMMON PURPOSE brainwashed sheep know what that is and dont want to know as long as they are ok Jack.

Log-in to Report

by tony white

18th January 2013, at 13:23:33

It is a disgusting state of affairs when pughs boys seem to be able to stifle free speech and deny even basic democracy in the council, the taxpayers deserve better than this disgusting dictatorship we are plagued with at the moment and whose only claim to fame is their sheer incompetence and arrogance of any council in living memory

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Delicious Icon

More News

1 - 2 - 3 - 4