Prison to close

By Ross Findon

Thursday, January 10, 2013

 

Prison to close

Camp Hill prison on the Isle of Wight is to close.

UPDATED 14:03*

CAMP Hill prison, part of HMP Isle of Wight, is to close.

The announcement was made by Secretary of State for Justice Chris Grayling today (Thursday).

He said the decision to close Camp Hill, along with eight other sites, was aimed at cutting costs and improving accommodation suitability.

Isle of Wight MP Andrew Turner said the decision was very disappointing and he was concerned about the impact on the local economy.

He is seeking a meeting with Mr Grayling to discuss the impact on the Island, what support there will be for staff and what will happen to the Camp Hill buildings.

The prison, which was built in 1912 and opened by Winston Churchill, holds around 600 prisoners and became part of HMP Isle of Wight in 2008, along with Parkhurst and Albany.

In his statement Mr Grayling said: "Our strategy for the custodial estate is to ensure that we have sufficient places to meet the demand of the courts whilst securing best value for money for the taxpayer.

"My intention is to have more adult male prison capacity available than we had in 2010 but at a much lower unit and overall cost.

"Our strategy for achieving this is to replace accommodation which is old, inefficient or has limited long-term strategic value with cheaper modern capacity which is designed to better meet the demand for prison places and supports our aim to drive down stubbornly high reoffending rates.

"I am also announcing today that the Government is to start feasibility work on a new prison that could hold more than 2,000 prisoners – around a quarter more than the largest current facility.

"At present, we have buildings within the prison estate which date back to the 18th Century. Prisons are not all located where we would want them to be to best meet the needs of the courts or support resettlement and there is an annual maintenance cost of approximately £184m.

"There is clear evidence that by replacing old uneconomic places with modern prison capacity we can drive substantial savings for the taxpayer and I am determined to do just that.

"Last year we opened a significant amount of new accommodation including 1,600 places at HMP Oakwood in the West Midlands. The average cost at Oakwood is £13,200 per place. This is less than half the average cost of existing prison places, and sets the benchmark for future costs. In order to further drive down unit costs in prisons, I can today announce that we plan to significantly increase capacity at four existing prisons by building additional houseblocks to provide up to 1,260 new modern and cost effective places.

"Our current intention is that new accommodation will be built at HMP Parc in Bridgend, HMP Peterborough in Cambridgeshire, HMP The Mount in Hertfordshire and HMP Thameside in London.

"These houseblocks, along with Oakwood, which is now reaching capacity, represent over 2,800 new places. "This provides the opportunity to close excess capacity elsewhere in the estate.

"I am therefore announcing that we will close around 2,600 old and uneconomic places through the closure of six prisons and the partial closure of accommodation in three other sites.

"The decision to close, or partially close places in these establishments is based on the suitability, sustainability and the cost of this accommodation.

"Closures form just one part of our strategy to improve the operation of our prison estate and drive down the costs to the public. We will also decommission 200 contractually crowded places at private prisons, which are not currently needed.

"We will continue to ensure that our estate reflects prison population demands, and in line with the falling population in the youth estate, I can also announce that we intend to negotiate a change to the function of HMYOI Ashfield and re-role it to a prison to hold adult male prisoners.

"I intend to work with the Youth Justice Board to review the operation of the youth estate to ensure that it provides effective education and training for young people whilst delivering value for money to the taxpayer.

"Furthermore, I am conscious that women offenders have particular needs and that the custodial female estate should be organised as effectively as possible to meet gender specific requirements whilst also delivering best value for the public.

"I have therefore asked officials to undertake a review of custodial arrangements for women. I expect this review to be completed by the summer.

"As part of our strategy to modernise the estate and significantly reduce unit and overall costs, I have asked officials to explore options for building a new prison to enable us to accelerate the closure of uneconomic capacity across the rest of the estate.

"We will consider the feasibility of sites in the North West, North Wales and in London in line with demand for places in these regions and I will provide further details to the House as this work progresses.

"Overall, this capacity reduction will save £63 million per year from the cost of running our prisons.

"These savings are in addition to the plans we have already set out to the House for how we propose to make significant cost reductions over the next few years through the application of an efficient benchmark for all public sector prisons, and through further competition of services.

"This Government is determined to ensure that we have a resilient custodial estate with sufficient capacity available to meet the demands to imprison those committed by the courts.

"We also intend to ensure that the cost of a prison place is dramatically reduced. The strategy I am outlining today will help achieve both these aims."

Mr Turner said: "This is very disappointing and I am of course very concerned about this announcement and the ramifications for Island residents and the local economy.  However, at least we are not suffering full closure of HMP Isle of Wight.

"The future of the national prison estate has been under review because keeping prisoners in ageing buildings presents particular challenges and they are very expensive to run and maintain. 

"Camp Hill was built in 1912 and houses category C prisoners who do not require the same levels of security as the category B prisoners in Albany and Parkhurst. 

"The Government believes that wherever possible prisoners should be incarcerated close to the communities they come from to enable them to keep in regular contact with their families which is considered important for their rehabilitation. 

"Of course a very low number of prisoners in HMP Isle of Wight are actually from the Island and family visits from the mainland can be problematic due to the cost and difficulty of getting here.   

"I will be seeking an early meeting with the Secretary of State to discuss the implications this will have on the Island’s economy, what can be done to support staff affected by the closure and the future of the actual buildings and grounds at Camp Hill.

"I will also be asking for meetings with the Prison Governor and members of staff to discuss the issues."

*HMP Isle of Wight governor Andy Lattimore said: "Clearly this is a sad day for HMP Isle of Wight as Camp Hill has been proud to protect the public and help reduce re-offending for so many years.

"We understand that this is absolutely not a reflection of our performance.

"I know that everything possible will be done to avoid compulsory redundancies by seeking to redeploy staff within HMP Isle of Wight and to establishments on the mainland, and by using the Voluntary Early Departure Scheme where appropriate.

"Work will also now begin to identify new allocations for prisoners which take account of their sentence plans and particular needs as far as is possible.

"I can assure the local community with whom we have worked so closely for so long that public protection will remain our priority throughout the closure process."

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?
Displaying the last 10 of 30 comments - Show All Comments

Log-in to Report

by John Evans

18th April 2013, at 18:28:13

I spent nearly a year in Camp Hill from Aug 2011 to May 2012 - 2 year sentence for failing to pay a Proceeds of Crime Order which I did not have the money to pay. Though the prison was very good and the staff really were fantastic, I think it's time we, as a society, stopped wasting £50,000 p.a. + per prisoner to lock up people who are not in any way a risk to the public. No wonder the country has no money and is in such debt - the wastage I have seen would bring you to tears. The legal profession spent (wasted) hundreds of thousands prosecuting and
defending me (legal aid) for Trade Mark Infringement! The prisons, particularly C cat prisons, are not protecting society from dangerous criminals, they are, in fact, cash cows mainly for the legal profession and their associates. The IOW economy may be a loser, SERCO, G4S, the ferry company, train operators and all those who shuttle prisoners to and thro from London to the IOW may lose out, but the tax payer will be a winner.

Log-in to Report

by Mike Stott

18th January 2013, at 15:06:53

It will be a disaster to the island economy. The amount of staff the prisons are losing on 1st April put £2,500,000 into the island economy every year in wages spent.

Log-in to Report

by alan naylor

11th January 2013, at 15:04:30

The closing of an antiquated prison in say Manchester or Leicester would have little affect on the local economy on the Isle of Wight its disasterus it just shows how vunerable the island is

Log-in to Report

by Ron Saunders

11th January 2013, at 13:37:13

I started my Prison Service career at this prison way back in 1972. Even then it was Dickensian. The constant upkeep and upgrading over the years would have cost a fortune. It did and probably still does provide employment for not only Prison Officer grades but also a lot of civilian grades as well .In relation to the prisoners they did like not to be sent here. They were mainly from the London area and visits from loved ones were infrequent. Many a time they would play so they could be shipped back to a prison nearer home.
Just before I retired from the service 10 years ago the policy was to have prisoners housed in prisons near to their home to facilitate visits, ,job interviews etc. Now this policy does not bode well for the other two prisons on our remote and isolated little island does it ?
Goodbye Camp Hill you gave me some good (and bad) memories.
Ron Saunders (served there 1972-1979)

Log-in to Report

by Peter Lewis

11th January 2013, at 08:47:36

Surely the case for a prison on the island is strengthened by the fact that it is , indeed , an island. The ability to close access in the event of a serious problem must be added value. The prisons are old , yes no doubt, so the answer, surely, is to build new ones. This would bring short term jobs in construction (assuming the tender has a built in social and communal clause allowing credit for employing locals, as being is used now in Wales) and secure (sorry no pun intended) the long term jobs for those in the service. Prison officer is one difficult job and I have a deep respect for most of the people who do it. I have previously stated my bias. My thoughts go out to the staff and their families.

Log-in to Report

by kevin froment

10th January 2013, at 23:19:45

it is a shame the prison is closing but i think its only the first part of the plan to close all of them, if the prison service have to pay as much as other haulage firms to bring lorries over then that expense saving alone will be considerable. sorry nearly went into another topic, arent all the prisons listed, if they are then they cant be torn down and replaced by trees, good idea though that is

Log-in to Report

by Dave Walter

10th January 2013, at 22:15:09

Get used to this news because its not going to get any better soon, fact is we all know this is just the start of closing all the prisons down over here. we need to promote the Island more for tourists and we need a quicker link to the mainland to get companies to invest in the Island therefore create jobs.

Log-in to Report

by LJ Parker

10th January 2013, at 21:58:08

After hearing this horrible news my thoughts are with all the hard working professional staff currently working at Camp Hill. As for those idiots who made this decision , I know from experience that they couldn't organise a p*** up in a brewery.

Log-in to Report

by Tim Brayford

10th January 2013, at 20:43:41

Well I suppose that people who work in the private sector could be taxed even more heavily to save well paid public sector jobs, but it is not so much a case of being unsympathetic but realistic, and new employment would be generated even if the site is returned to woodland.

Log-in to Report

by Richard Curzon Beet

10th January 2013, at 20:08:07

A tragedy for all involved and another blow to the island economy. What I would like to know is how much the cost of transporting prisoners over here by ferry has influenced this decision? Do The ferry companies offer concessions to the Prison Service? If not, what is the annual cost?

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.