Troubled school branded inadequate

By Emily Pearce

Thursday, January 17, 2013

 

Troubled school branded inadequate

The new Cowes Enterprise College building which has been blighted by delays. Picture by Robin Crossley.

INSPECTORS have branded an Isle of Wight high school inadequate, placing it special measures after finding it was failing to provide an acceptable standard of education.

Ofsted inspectors visited Cowes Enterprise College in November and found the quality of teaching and leadership was inadequate, as was the achievement of pupils, according to a damning report published today (Thursday).

"Too much teaching is inadequate and too few lessons enable students to make good progress.

"Examination results are not high enough given students' abilities. Many lessons do not challenge students. Students are given work that is too easy or repeats things they already know.

"Many lessons do not interest students. There are weaknesses in the curriculum. The sixth form is also inadequate," said the report.

"The school's leaders have not done enough to improve teaching and the school is not improving quickly enough. Leaders have too positive a view of the school's effectiveness and do not have an accurate enough understanding of its strengths and weaknesses," it added.

Inspectors found the behaviour and safety of students required improvement, although students were polite, friendly and co-operative and attendance had increased.

It was also found leaders were ambitious for the school — although they had become distracted by the move to the new building — and the governing body recognised its weaknesses and had challenged leaders to make improvements.

Principal Jonathan Russell resigned just weeks after the inspection and has been replaced by interim principal James Stewart.

Chair of governors Alan Wells admitted the report was extremely disappointing, but said governors and leaders were taking the challenges it presented seriously and had sought the help of an education troubleshooter to improve the school.

"We regret Ofsted regulations have made it impossible for us to comment until now which has resulted in a great deal of speculation which we appreciate has been very unsettling for parents, students and staff.

"We are taking the results of the inspection very seriously and are confident that, with the support we already have in place, the college will achieve the high expectations and improvement that the trust and governing body have for pupils, parents and the community," said Mr Wells.

Under special measures the school will be subject to regular monitoring from Ofsted.

The dismal Ofsted report is the latest blow for the troubled school, run by the Cowes Pathfinder Trust.

As previously reported, the opening of its new £32 million building has been delayed by a year and health and safety concerns have been raised regarding the shabby state of the existing building.

The Isle of Wight Council has launched an investigation into the delays and poor project management, and two senior council officers have been suspended over the debacle.

A public meeting will be held at the school next Thursday, when school bosses will answer parents' questions and explain how the school will be improved.

Cowes Enterprise College Ofsted report

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?
Displaying the last 10 of 15 comments - Show All Comments

Log-in to Report

by michael price

21st January 2013, at 19:51:34

Alan Wells has been at the forefront of this disaster from the start and needs to be wedged out of his corner and given his sword to fall on. He has been clinging onto his little empire for too long. He should be supporting the teachers and not speaking on local radio saying 'they should be able to teach in mud huts' Just think how the teachers feel listening to that! Whilst we do agree there is a vast variation between some of the teachers and their standards, the governors have had a very good opportunity in the change over to the two-tier system to weed out some of the weaker performing staff. Alan Wells has only one thing to promote - and that is himself. Glad we had the last chance to talk to Mr. Russell and tell him how badly the council have treated him. Shame he had to go. He was the best thing that has happened to this school lately.

Log-in to Report

by Maria Green

18th January 2013, at 09:45:13

Even after the publication of the OFSTED report, they are only worried about children wearing their Blazers, I would think they had far more important things to worry about at the moment then whether or not a child has his Blazer on, but no, that seems to be far more important than any OFSTED report, I suggest you get your priorities right, and would suggest the full Governing body resign, if you won't do the decent thing and go, then perhaps it's time for a 'vote of no confidence', let a new board of Governors take over - one that cares, Alan Wells, you and your cronies should hang your heads in shame, this is our Children's Education you are playing with,

Log-in to Report

by Marcus Wallis

17th January 2013, at 22:07:22

Please please please Governors and Council read and accept the first paragraph of page 3 of the report. You don't have the capacity to do what's required, it's there in black and white, no excuses just go and go now.

Log-in to Report

by Marcus Wallis

17th January 2013, at 21:46:33

How can the people be galvanised to form/support an independent council? I get the feeling a lot of IW Tories are embarrassed by this bunch of fools and even they might vote Independent in order to facilitate a change in leadership both party and council wise.

Log-in to Report

by Alan Bennett

17th January 2013, at 20:40:38

Why is it that the Governors always have to try and gloss over the crass incompetence by stating ' governors and leaders were taking the challenges it presented seriously' Why cant they, even now, say 'This report shows we have not safeguarded our students education and we should all be replaced, especially after we managed to lie to students and parents about the true state of the 32 million rebuild for 6 months'
Mr Russel knew what was coming in this report, [as all Headteachers do] so did the honorable thing and fell on his sword. It's too much of a shame that Mr Wells and the others at fault here, will cling on to their jobs regardless of public opinion and thy will, of course, be backed up by the equally insensitive, egotistical and autocratic senior members of the Isle of Wight Council

Log-in to Report

by Marcus Wallis

17th January 2013, at 19:49:30

I have to admit that I totally agree with Mr Web, I know it's easy to lay the boot in when things go wrong (and they do no matter who is in power) but the current Council must have set a record for blunder after blunder, error after error and yet they manage to convince each other that it's not really their fault. Come on IW let's really try something new and innovative, Ecoisland? What about Indyisland?

Log-in to Report

by David Web

17th January 2013, at 19:24:24

Come May listen to Martin Bell and Elect a truly INDEPENDENT Council who will run things a lot better and actually listen

The whole revamped education system has been a complete disaster this is just the latest in a long line of failures conceived by the councils failure to plan or monitor the situation particularly the lack of project management at the school site and the impact on learning as a result and this OFSTED report backs up those failures, no wonder Russell resigned, just hope the likes of Dawn Cousins and Alan Wells do the only honorable thing lefty and leave now before they do more damage

Log-in to Report

by Marcus Wallis

17th January 2013, at 19:00:44

When will Mr Wells realise that the people of Cowes didn't want him as their Councillor and don't want him as the Chairman of Governors either.

Log-in to Report

by Dave Dawson

17th January 2013, at 18:42:54

Alan Wells - RESIGN NOW

Log-in to Report

by Mr Justice

17th January 2013, at 18:36:40

Very disappointing for the children and parents and yet another County Hall education failure - not that you would know that from their reactions. Mr Wells speaks as if he was unconnected with this failure rather than Chairman of governors. Mssrs Beynon and Pugh (the self styled education experts) the same. This council has disintegrated into chaos. The sooner they are all removed by the electorate the better.

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Most Read

  1. Job losses at Isle of Wight College

    Monday, May 20, 2013

  2. Thousands affected by power cut

    Monday, May 20, 2013

  3. Former GP joins NHS trust board

    Monday, May 20, 2013

  4. Desalination plan for the Island

    Tuesday, May 21, 2013

  5. Literary festival lines up big names

    Monday, May 20, 2013