Wightlink debt issue raised with business secretary

By Ross Findon

Thursday, January 24, 2013

 

Wightlink debt issue raised with business secretary

An Isle of Wight delegation could be formed to further highlight impact of cuts to Wightlink ferry services.

UPDATED 17:08*

FEARS Wightlink debts to parent company Macquarie have led to damaging service cuts and redundancies have been raised by Andrew Turner MP in a meeting with business secretary Vince Cable.

The meeting on Monday was described as extremely constructive by Mr Turner, who said he hoped an Isle of Wight delegation, including union representatives and commuters, could be formed to further highlight the impact of the cuts on the Island.

Wightlink’s funding arrangements were among the issues discussed by Mr Turner and Mr Cable.

Mr Turner said: "Yarmouth resident, Peter Bonnell, raised this issue recently at a public meeting. I have followed it up because I believe Islanders deserve clarity about the funding of a company which provides us with lifeline services.

"The discussion with the Secretary of State was extremely wide ranging and I am pleased to say he very quickly understood the impact that the ferry services have, not least because he has used them to travel to the Island himself in a private capacity.

"I am also trying to find out if the complex inter-company financial arrangements are in place to minimise tax liability in the UK and will pass the Secretary of State the answers I receive to the questions I have asked."

He added: "I now intend to set up a meeting with Stephen Hammond MP, the Transport Minister responsible for Maritime Affairs, and I hope that can include a delegation to explain the impact the latest service cuts are having on individuals and the Island as a whole."

*Isle of Wight Trades Union Council spokesman Steve Butler said they welcomed the intention of a meeting with Mr Hammond, when they would present him with the facts.

"We expect action," said Mr Butler.

Reporter: ross.findon@iwcp.co.uk

Comments

Log-in or register to comment on this story.

By ticking "Remember me" you agree to a cookie being stored on your computer - no personal data is shared.

Forgotten your password?
Displaying the last 10 of 39 comments - Show All Comments

Log-in to Report

by James Bateman

28th January 2013, at 07:58:56

@Crowe

£2.8m will get you a couple of the penthouses on Cowes sea front. Alternatively, £2.8m will get Wightlink into the black, with enough cash left over for bonuses to incentivise company directors, and perhaps a decent rebranding/relaunch party for a few of the Island's mover shakers.

Log-in to Report

by K Thornton

26th January 2013, at 21:27:41

Shane
The truth is that Wightlink are unable to lower prices due to crippling interest rates on the original loan to purchase the company, circa 17%. Now the interesting thing is that the company is owned by McQuarrie, an Australian bank. The loan to purchase Wightlink was given by another division of McQuarrie, therefore it is effectively charging itself an extortionate rate, effectively to write off tax as interest on the loan is deductable against any profits. If the loan was made at normal commercial rates of 6 - 7% ticket prices would be half of what they are, whilst still allowing the company to make a profit. It is a very similar method to Starbucks, but instead of interest at Starbucks it is outrageous inflated franchise costs payable to an overseas company in a favourable tax haven. Simply put we are all funding an outrageous tax dodge for a foreign bank and it MUST stop. Andrew Turner, show us your worth.

Log-in to Report

by shane randall

26th January 2013, at 18:31:31

I had to make three mainland trips by car/van in December.
unfortunately my preferred route Portsmouth/A3 wasnt taken because of the higher price Wightlink wanted.
simple maths tells me that, if you have a half full ferry at a higher price it wont take long before its costing more to run the ferry than what it is taking in.
however wouldn't it be better to offer a cheaper price and fill the ferry. thus making more money per trip. thus reducing the debt. then we wont need a fixed link and almost everyone would be happy.

Log-in to Report

by Mike Crowe

25th January 2013, at 20:14:24

Wouldn't it be better to put that £2.8m into more housing for our children's children?

Log-in to Report

by James Bateman

25th January 2013, at 20:11:52

I think that Wightlink offer a very reasonably priced service, and that we IOWers owe it to them to support the company if it hits hard times. If every Island resident donated £20, it would raise £2.8m which would allow them to repay existing debt and then raise ticket prices in line with RPI growth.

Log-in to Report

by Mike Crowe

25th January 2013, at 17:10:52

There you are folks.

No bridge. No new ferry on the Fishbourne/GunWharf run. Millions of people. Roof and Road everywhere. No natural beuty because the selfish people want want want

Log-in to Report

by neil jacks

25th January 2013, at 16:43:21

When it is worth it then thats the time to worry because they will either have to find Oil, Gas or Gold on or around the island to warrant the investment needed. Until then people, sleep easy in your beds.

Log-in to Report

by neil jacks

25th January 2013, at 16:38:46

Ha ha third world. sounds like someone who keeps talkin about blinkers has had some of them dodgy burgers. There will be no bridge cus the isle of wight just aint worth it. Face facts, if it could have been or needed to have been done, then it would have already happened. Mike is right, its nothing to do with cost, its just not worth it.

Log-in to Report

by T Rollingsworth

25th January 2013, at 16:25:42

In practicalities it would have to go through on the Lymington route due to shipping lanes and lowest amount of distribution. Obviously this means massive changes in the new forrest which is where there will be serious issues due to conservation and such.

However, the point i was trying to make is that there is nowhere it could be built on the IoW as people would just moan that it's ruining a view or is generating too much traffic etc etc etc. Just read any post on here which discusses new development of any kind...

Log-in to Report

by Mike Crowe

25th January 2013, at 14:00:25

T Rollingsworth

Have you ever thought about where one would go?

Go on, forget your head stuck in the sand attitude.

Give it a try.

BUT, you will need to look around at what is happening :-)

It's not hard ;-)

Try it.

Any views or opinions presented in the comments above are solely those of the author and do not represent those of the Isle of Wight County Press.

Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Delicious Icon

More News

1 - 2 - 3 - 4

Most Read

  1. Homes plan in top hotel’s grounds

    Saturday, May 18, 2013

  2. Down the hatch

    Sunday, May 19, 2013

  3. Hundreds turn out for Race for Life

    Sunday, May 19, 2013

  4. New way of receiving prescriptions

    Saturday, May 18, 2013

  5. Having an ice time

    Saturday, May 18, 2013